2023 – First Baptist Church, Mount Vernon, Kentucky
2022 – Southside Baptist Church, Fulton, Missouri
2021 – Connect Church of Algiers, New Orleans, Louisiana
2020 – Laurel Creek Baptist Church, Rock Island, Tennessee
2019 – Laurel Creek Baptist Church Rock Island, Tennessee
2018 – New Hope Baptist Church, DeQuincy, Louisiana
2017 – Lake Pointe Baptist Church, Dadeville, Alabama
2016 – Southside Baptist Church, Fulton, Missouri
2015 – Southside Baptist Church, Fulton, Missouri
2014 – Bethel Baptist Church, Citronelle, Alabama
2013 – First Baptist Church, Circleville, Ohio
2012 – Community Baptist Church, Ripley, Mississippi
2011 – Westland Heights Baptist Church, Fort Worth, Texas
2010 – United Believers Community Church, Kansas City, Missouri
2009 – Ebenezer Baptist Church, Dunlap, Tennessee
2008 – Foothills Baptist Church, Mountain View, Arkansas
2007 – Chestnut Street Baptist Church, Ellensburg, Washington
2006 – Southside Baptist Church, Athens, Alabama
2005 – Galilean Baptist Church, Centerville, Indiana
2004 – Central Valley Baptist Church, Meridian, Idaho
2003 – Indian Creek Baptist Church, Mineral Wells, Texas
2002 – Brookwood Baptist Church, Hillsboro, Oregon
2001 – Brookwood Baptist Church, Hillsboro, Oregon
2000 – Village Baptist Church, Bella Vista, Arkansas
1999 – Farmington Baptist Church, Farmington, Maine
1998 – University Baptist Church, Anchorage, Alaska
1997 – Temple Baptist Church, Sparks, Nevada
1996 – First Baptist Church, Sequim, Washington
1995 – Derby Hills Baptist Church, Loveland, Colorado
1994 – Westside Baptist Church, Great Falls, Montana
1993 – High View Baptist Church, Woodland Park, Colorado
1992 – Southside Baptist Church, Ft. Collins, Colorado
1991 – Anchorage, Alaska
1990 – Phoenix, Arizona
1989 – Billings, Montana